Betsy Ames
Username
Betsy Ames
Proposer First Name
Betsy
Proposer Email
betsy@nehers.org
Proposer Last Name
Ames
Proposer Company/Organization
Northeast Home Energy Rating System Alliance
Proposer Phone
(978) 633-3013
Proposer Job Title
Executive Director
Boston 2023 Areas of Focus
Proposed Session Description
RESNET has formed a working group for the development of a RESNET Standard for Materials Embodied Carbon (MEC). A baseline is needed in order to create an Embodied Carbon Reference Home for the calculation of an index as compared to a Rated Home for the new standard. NEHERS will be conducting a baseline study in partnership with Rocky Mountain Institute (RMI) and possibly others. We will review the findings of benchmark studies done in Canada, illustrate the challenges/opportunities involved in setting default values, discuss opportunities for program incentives, and explore workforce development possibilities for HERS Raters, as the software technology is scaled nationally, and review the language of the proposed Standard itself.
Diversity and Inclusiveness
This is a critical environmental and social justice issue that goes beyond adding solar panels and eating less meat. Global majority and indigenous people around the world are calling on the wealthy nations to address our relationship to poor nations, which have for centuries been based on the extraction of resources and labor for the profit of a few, but to the detriment of all.
Indigenous populations make up only 5% of the world's population but have preserved over 80% of the world's biodiversity. In contrast, the US also makes up about 5% of the worlds population, but emits roughly 25% of the global carbon emissions. Wealthy nations must do everything in our power to curb our disproportionate amount of emissions, so that those with the ancient knowledge can lead us toward regaining balance.
Within the US, the dynamics of extraction also draw labor and resources from people of the global majority and indigenous people, women, and working and middle class people, for the benefit of the global corporate elite. Curbing our overconsumption of resources (and thereby also our disproportionate amount of emissions) is also an act of liberation for many domestic constituencies who are perpetually dominated by the very same forces that exploit labor and resources and displace indigenous knowledge world-wide.
Sequestering carbon is an essential part of shifting our worldview from extraction to regeneration. Calculating embodied carbon emissions is a key step towards being able to quantify and then reduce, and ultimately, sequester carbon in the built environment. The time is short. We must act now.
Learning Objectives
1) Understand the significance and urgency of reducing materials embodied carbon emission
2) Recognize the current state of the technology and workflow challenges and opportunities; that it is possible to track MEC emissions now, and even more precisely in the future
3) Relate operation emissions to MEC emissions within the context of a unified measuring metric like our proposed Total Emissions Impact
4) Advocate on behalf of our initiative within their respective networks.
Has this session been presented before?
No
Additional Comments
This past spring, we presented "A Proposal for a New RESNET Standard on Embodied Carbon" which laid out our reasoning for making our proposal to RESNET. A lot has happened since then! Now that the working group has been formed to explore the creation of this standard, we have shifted our focus towards creating the baseline needed for the Standard's reference home, in addition, to drafting the language of the Standard itself. We would be honored to have the opportunity to provide a window into our efforts for the members of NESEA.
Session Format
Presentation followed by facilitated discussion or breakout groups
Session Format Details
We would be happy to provide an overview of the work we are doing and then facilitate breakout rooms on the different topics (baseline/benchmark, technology/workflow, program incentives, unified metric, and standard language).
Recommended Length
90-minute session
Strongest Content Connection - Boston 2023
Comments about your speaker roster
Chris Magwood is only available on the last day of the conference.
Reviewer 1
Chase, Tom
Proposal #
143
Committee Decision
Rejected
Full Description
Materials Embodied Carbon refers to the carbon emissions generated in the first three stages of a building material's life-cycle, (A1-A3), known as "cradle-to-gate" emissions. These emissions exist in the atmosphere before construction begins and account for 60-90% of the material's full life cycle emissions. At this time, the residential marketplace is not currently served by any comprehensive carbon standard and the lack of such a standard leaves room to shoot ourselves in the carbon footprint by building high performance buildings with high GWP materials in an effort to reduce operational emissions over time.
It is imperative to develop a standard to include MEC now! Such a standard would create a scalable, vetted framework around which municipalities, program administrators, and other stakeholders could build programs. Standards make training and oversight consistent. Standards provide accreditation of professionals and tools, quality assurance, and verification of energy savings and performance for a variety of programs, including energy efficient mortgages (EEMs) and the EPA’s ENERGY STAR Homes Program, among others.
In order to begin tracking reductions in MEC emissions, it is necessary to create a Reference Home by which to compare a Rated Home; we are running a benchmark study to establish a baseline by which future reductions can be compared. Developing the workflow for raters, integrating the software systems and rising to the challenge of determining how to set default values until more granular data is available are some of the logistics our group is sorting out. As these technical issues are resolved, opportunities will abound for forward-thinking HERS raters to include these calculations in the scope of their workflow and to be able to advise builders, architects and municipalities of up-front carbon savings, including the potential to store/sequester carbon in buildings, before materials are procured. This will impact a significant component of emissions related to construction of buildings that will make a difference within the 7-year time horizon we have to mitigate climate change.
This new standard would also allow us to evaluate not only energy efficiency, but also carbon efficiency- both operational and embodied. We envision creating a single metric for calculating the damage to the atmosphere in (measured as CO2e tons*years) from both HERS models and Embodied carbon models for the same period of time. These metrics (one linear and one exponential) can be put together for the calculation of Total Emissions Impact Index for that period of time. (Total Emissions Impact Index = Rated Home Emissions Impact / Reference Home Emissions Impact * 100.). This will create an expandable standard which can incorporate data on other forms of carbon emission from other stages of the life cycle (like transportation or end-of-life emissions) as it becomes available.
In creating the draft of the standard language we would like to propose, we are simultaneously defining how an entire industry can begin to quantify, track and reduce these up-front carbon emissions, while at the same time setting the baseline against which future reductions will be compared. This initiative will:
- improve our communication and build a broader consensus around the important, urgency, and feasibility of reducing MEC emissions
- significantly increase the number of buildings that can contribute to the solution and not the cause of the problem (while utilizing readily available materials currently in big box stores)
- and incentivize a robust, dedicated and diverse workforce that can bridge across disciplines (architects, builders, engineers, appraisers, real estate agents, municipalities, utilities, and code officials) and be fully equipped to make a significant dent in the emissions from the construction industry, both new construction and renovations and additions, within the extremely limited time frame we have.