Laura Henderson
Username
Laura Henderson
Proposer First Name
Laura
Proposer Email
lhenderson@ecosystem-energy.com
Proposer Last Name
Henderson
Proposer Phone
(647) 206-2723
Proposer Job Title
Marketing Specialist
Proposed Session Description
We’ll present a completed electrification project in a NYC coop building that was financially viable, constructible, and with incentives, achieved at a lower cost of ownership vs. the status quo. It shows the value of a proactive approach to asset renewal and opportunity cost of replacing assets at failure. By planning and investing well, these projects can achieve multiple outcomes beyond LL97 compliance. We’ll discuss the technical solutions and asset renewal strategies that lead to success.
Why is this session important?
Building owners and managers in NYC are all too aware that LL97 fines are imminent, and many are looking for electrification retrofit solutions that are both financially viable and technically constructible. A range of electrification options exist, but a “hybrid” or “flexible” approach is key to capturing as many benefits as possible. (In fact, a recent 2023 MIT Center for Real Estate study* found flexible electrification to be most profitable in 99% of 10,000 scenarios, versus full electrification in 24% of those scenarios, when accounting for changing future greenhouse emission penalties, investments in local electric grid, local real estate market conditions and energy prices.). It’s essential for building owners, managers, and residents to view their asset renewal needs through a decarbonization lens, moving away from simple payback to lifecycle cost analysis and total cost of ownership. It’s equally important to distinguish between asset renewal that is transformational (essential for decarbonization) vs incremental (energy efficiency). We will present an example of a successful hybrid electrification project completed in a Manhattan coop building with an existing hydronic system. This project not only achieves LL97 compliance to 2050 but also benefitted from incentives and support from NYSERDA, and it solved longstanding thermal comfort issues familiar to all NYC residents.
*S. Zheng, J. Palacios, A. Valdez, Quantifying The Financial Value of Building Decarbonization Technology Under Uncertainty: Integrating Energy Modeling and Investment Analysis, MIT Center for Real Estate Research Paper No. 23/07. (2023)
Diversity and Inclusiveness
With our choice of speakers, we prioritized audience learning over diversity. The two proposed speakers will draw upon deep expertise with the project, electrification strategies, and incentives.
Learning Objectives
Understand feasible electrification options that capture the best overall value for your building(s) long term.
Learn strategies to identify optimal asset renewal and interventions through a decarbonization lens to invest prudently in your building.
Evaluate design concepts for financial feasibility and technical constructability in existing NYC buildings.
Learn how incentives can change the total cost of ownership over the asset’s lifecycle.
Has this session been presented before?
Yes
When and Where?
Ecosystem has presented this case study to different audiences and with different emphasis twice in the past year:
• Council of New York Cooperatives and Condominiums webinar, Debunking Electrification Myths, with First Service Energy (August 2022).
• Building Energy Exchange, Climate Mobilization Act Series: Cutting Carbon in Co-Ops and Condos; Local Law 97 Pathways, (May 2023).
Ecosystem has also presented the topic of electrification numerous times, most often to higher education audiences. Further examples include:
• As part of Climate Week NYC 2020, together with Second Nature, Cornell and Tufts Universities: "Toward Carbon Neutrality in Higher Education: Cost-Effective, Actionable Pathways to a Net-Zero Future"
• As part of BuildingEnergy NYC 2019, together with Vassar College: “Reduce, Rethink, Recover, Repurpose; Low-Cost Approach to Prepare your Facility for Electrified Heating and 80% GHG Reductions.”
Additional Comments
See above for conference specifics.
Target Audiences Level of Expertise
Level 2 - Some prior knowledge helpful.
NYC 2023 Areas of Focus
Recommended Length
60-minute session
Strongest Content Connection - NYC 2023
Reviewer 1
O'Hagan, Kristy
Reviewer 2
Rajan, Amritha
Proposal #
142
Committee Decision
Being Considered